From Retrospective Audit to Prospective Certainty: Domestic Advance Pricing Agreements, Shared Services and VAT Valuation in Kenya
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.70619/vol6iss12pp56-74-987Keywords:
Advance Pricing Agreements; domestic transfer pricing; shared services; intra-group services; VAT; open market value; section 23; section 18A; section 18G; comparability; Kenya Revenue Authority; cooperative compliance; tax certaintyAbstract
Kenya's introduction of Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) under section 18G of the Income Tax Act, Cap. 470, represents an important move from retrospective tax controversy towards prospective tax certainty. The development is particularly significant because Kenya's domestic corporate environment increasingly contains related-party transactions involving preferential tax regimes, integrated corporate groups and centralized shared-service arrangements. The emerging framework, however, raises a broader policy question. While transfer-pricing rules seek to ensure that controlled transactions reflect the arm's-length principle, applying that principle in practice can be difficult where the transaction involves highly integrated group services for which no exact uncontrolled comparable exists. Recent Kenyan transfer-pricing disputes show disagreements over the functional characterization of intra-group services, benchmarking, allocation keys, and the choice between one-sided and two-sided transfer-pricing methodologies. The problem is compounded when the same economic transaction is subsequently examined under Value Added Tax (VAT). Section 13 of the VAT Act, 2013 provides that where a supplier and recipient are related, the taxable value is the open market value of the supply. The coexistence of an income-tax transfer-pricing analysis and a VAT open-market-value analysis creates a potential administrative coordination problem, as different valuation assumptions apply to the same transaction. This paper argues that Kenya should use its emerging APA framework to address this uncertainty through a targeted domestic APA mechanism. The proposed framework would not eliminate the Commissioner's anti-avoidance powers under section 23 of the Income Tax Act. Rather, it would establish a clearer relationship between sections 18A, 18G and 23: section 18A identifies qualifying domestic related-party transactions, section 18G provides prospective certainty regarding transfer-pricing methodology, and section 23 preserves the Commissioner's ability to challenge arrangements involving tax avoidance, material misrepresentation, non-disclosure or material departure from agreed critical assumptions. The paper further proposes a "no reliable comparable" pathway within the APA Regulations for transactions involving integrated group/shared services. It recommends that taxpayers and the Commissioner should be able to agree prospectively on the most appropriate transfer-pricing methodology where an exact uncontrolled comparable cannot reasonably be identified. Finally, the paper proposes an amendment to section 13 of the VAT Act requiring the Commissioner to consider an applicable APA's functional analysis, comparability analysis, and methodology and valuation parameters when determining open market value. The proposal does not seek to merge income-tax and VAT valuation or automatically deem an APA price to be the VAT value. Instead, it seeks coordinated administration while preserving the distinct statutory purposes of each tax. The paper concludes that Kenya's emerging APA regime should evolve from a primarily transfer-pricing instrument into a broader cooperative-compliance mechanism that provides certainty for genuine commercial transactions while preserving strong safeguards against domestic tax arbitrage and abusive arrangements.
References
Kenyan Legislation
Republic of Kenya. Income Tax Act, Cap. 470.
Republic of Kenya. Value Added Tax Act, No. 35 of 2013.
Republic of Kenya. Finance Act, 2025.
Republic of Kenya. Special Economic Zones Act, No. 16 of 2015.
Regulations and Administrative Materials
Kenya Revenue Authority. Draft Income Tax (Advance Pricing Agreement) Regulations, 2025.
Kenya Revenue Authority. Public Notice: The Draft Income Tax (Advance Pricing Agreement) Regulations, 2025 and the Draft Income Tax (Minimum Top Up Tax) Regulations, 2025.
Kenyan Cases
ECP Kenya Limited v Commissioner of Domestic Taxes, Appeal 335 of 2022 [2023] KETAT 969 (KLR).
H.P. Gauff Ingenieure GMBH & Co KG v Commissioner of Domestic Taxes, Appeal 442 of 2020 [2024] KETAT 106 (KLR).
HP Gauff Ingenieure Gmbh & Co Kg v Commissioner of Domestic Taxes, Tax Appeal E442 of 2020 [2026] KETAT 63 (KLR).
Commissioner of Domestic Taxes v H.P. Gauff Ingenieure GMBH Company Limited, Tax Appeal E057 of 2020 [2021] KEHC 206 (KLR).
Commissioner of Domestic Taxes v Swift East Africa Limited, Tax Appeal E201 of 2021 [2023] KEHC 1271 (KLR).
Commissioner of Domestic Taxes & another v Integrated Payment Solutions Limited & another, Income Tax Appeal E180 of 2021 [2023] KEHC 3556 (KLR).
International Materials
OECD. Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations.
OECD. Transfer Pricing Country Profile: Kenya.
OECD. BEPS Action 8–10 Reports and Guidance on Intra-Group Services.
United Kingdom. Taxation (International and Other Provisions) Act 2010.
India. Income Tax Department. Materials on Advance Pricing Agreements and Specified Domestic Transactions.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Daniel Ngugi Gitau

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.